Irving v Penguin Books & Lipstadtcase 1996‑I‑1113 · QBD
6 reports
expert reports

Expert reports for the defence

Six expert reports framed the defence case. Each was served pursuant to the Order of Master Trench dated 15 December 1998 directing that each party may adduce expert evidence from historians and political scientists. Five address particular aspects of the historiography (shootings, gassing, systematic character, Hitler's role, right-wing networks); van Pelt's addresses the architecture of Auschwitz.

CB

Evidence for the Implementation of the Final Solution

Christopher R. Browning

120 paragraphs · 5 sections · ~1.5h read

Documents the evidence for the shooting operations on Soviet territory after June 1941, the gassing operations at Belzec, Sobibor and Treblinka, the Wannsee Conference and Operation Reinhard.

RE

David Irving, Hitler and Holocaust Denial

Richard J. Evans

1,367 paragraphs · 6 sections · ~15h read

The principal report on Irving’s historiography. Examines Lipstadt’s allegations — that Irving is a discredited historian, a Holocaust denier, a manipulator of documents, and an apologist for Hitler — against Irving’s published books and speeches.

HF

David Irving, Holocaust Denial, and his Connections to Right Wing Extremists and Neo-National Socialism (Neo-Nazism) in Germany

Hajo Funke

370 paragraphs · 8 sections · ~3h read

Addresses the defence allegation that Irving has allied himself with representatives of a variety of extremist and antisemitic groups and individuals. Maps Irving’s appearances at NPD, DVU and Association for Free Journalism events.

PL

Hitler's Role in the Persecution of the Jews by the Nazi Regime: Electronic Version

Heinz Peter LongerichReport I

305 paragraphs · 24 sections · ~1.5h read

First of two Longerich reports. Argues from the documentary record that Hitler was the moving force behind the persecution and ultimate murder of European Jewry — against Irving’s “no order” thesis.

PL

The Systematic Character of the National Socialist Policy for the Extermination of the Jews

Heinz Peter LongerichReport II

249 paragraphs · 6 sections · ~2h read

Second Longerich report. Argues that the policy was systematic, not the sum of local initiatives — against Irving’s claim that the killings on the Eastern Front were unauthorised excesses.

vP

The Van Pelt Report

Robert Jan van Pelt

257 paragraphs · 4 sections · ~4.5h read

The defence’s architectural and forensic report on Auschwitz-Birkenau, central to the second half of the trial. Crematoria 2 and 3, the Leichenkeller, the roof apertures, the Vrba-Wetzler report, the chemistry of Zyklon B.

— note — Each report is reproduced in full from the trial record. Paragraph numbering and footnotes are preserved as in the original submission.