Irving v Penguin Books & Lipstadtcase 1996‑I‑1113 · QBD
profile
RE

Professor Richard John Evans

expert witness

Professor Sir Richard John Evans (born 1947), Regius Professor of History at the University of Cambridge. Defence expert. His ~740-paragraph report addresses Irving’s historiography across 18 specific case studies and is the principal expert document in the trial.

Where they spoke

Each cell = one of the 32 sitting days. Bar height = share of that day's turns spoken.

DayDateTurnsFirst lineChapters spoken in
Day 18 10 Feb 546 L0166 Richard Evans sworn — defence's most damaging historian witnessEvans's use of Irving's diariesIrving's racism + photos of his racially-diverse staffArchive access + 'international Jewish conspiracy' lineAfternoon — Evans's report methodologyIrving's new-document discoveries + David Abraham comparison
Day 19 14 Feb 689 L0032 Evans on the definition of Holocaust denialIrving's alleged links to antisemites + Hitler's adjutantsThe Hitler diaries detour + the Hamburg/Rumanian-Jews photographContinued document-by-document examinationAfternoon session
Day 20 15 Feb 665 L0087 Procedural opening — Evans day 3Auschwitz authenticity + Irving's 1986 Australia press-conference quoteAllied propaganda — Churchill's 1943 'we have no evidence' minuteAnne Frank diary authenticityHöss memoirs + Irving's Leuchter-preface 'swindled' framingIrving's antisemitism defenceAfternoon — Kristallnacht discussion with EvansIrving's relationship with prominent Holocaust deniers'Straightening out' the IHR + selective Bruns readingSydnor on Irving's admiration of HitlerHofmann's role in Hitler's 1924 trial
Day 21 16 Feb 806 L0005 Procedural opening — Evans day 4Bruckner adjutant statementColonel Nicolaus von Below — Hitler's Luftwaffe adjutantOther nationwide programmes against Jews in GermanyEberstein telegram + the chain of Kristallnacht ordersGoebbels Old Town Hall speech as evidence Hitler initiated KristallnachtWitness schedulingUlrich von Hassell diary + Hess's appeal to HitlerHitler intervening on behalf of the Jewish populationHimmler-Heydrich 30 November 1941 phone log
Day 22 17 Feb 759 L0007 Procedural opening — Evans day 5 (final day of cross-exam)Insufficient source references in Irving's workIngrid Weckert + Reichskristallnacht death-tollThe Riga shootings — number killedProcedural concerns + Evans's scholarship critiqueAfternoon — completion of Evans cross-examinationClose + setup for next sequence
Day 23 21 Feb 900 L0071 Evans recalled — Weckert credibility + Goebbels diaryGoebbels–Hitler relationship + 'pushing at an open door'Hitler's 25 January 1942 Table Talk — 'pulling teeth'Secrecy in the Third Reich + Horthy 16-17 April 1943 meetingAfternoon — the Engel diaryChrista Schroeder + the 1991 'Warsaw uprising' editRome October 1943 — deportation of the JewsRibbentrop's knowledge + Rampton re-examines EvansEvans re-examined by Rampton